review by Aram Siu Wai Collier,
Toronto Reel Asian International Film Festival - November 2006
All you "fakes", "sell-outs" and especially "bad writers" take note:  there are a lot of
things wrong with Frank Chin.  The Asian American writer, playwright, actor, scholar
and activist of incomparable passion has been both revered and hated - sometimes
by the same person.  And he's likely to make your blood boil AND laugh out loud in
this latest feature from veteran documentarian Curtis Choy.

As part of the American Civil Rights movement of the 1960s, the political
consciousness of Asian Americans shifted to focus on multi-ethnic solidarity with an
emphasis on self-determination and (re)telling the history of Asians in America outside
the traditional racist institutions that made such a movement necessary.  Frank Chin
planted himself in the eye of this storm through his exhaustive work as a playwright,
novelist and activist, quickly garnering a reputation as the veritable polemicist (his
feuds about literary authenticity with writers Amy tan, David Henry Hwang and Maxine
Hong Kingston are hilariously bitter and legendary).  Although his contributions to the
Asian American movement are immeasurable, he remains widely unacknowledged.  
Chin would even be a "Renaissance Man" if only more people liked him.  Instead, he's
more like the embarrassing uncle of Asian America - he's family, but sometimes you
wish he wouldn't show up.

Director Choy is himself a fixture in Asian America with his seminal films
The Fall of
The I-Hotel
and Dupont Guy: The Schiz of Grant Avenue.  What's Wrong With Frank
Chin?
showcases 30 years of his community-based documentary work through
archival photos, print and film, and interviews with numerous Chin contemporaries.  
Choy's sly editing creates visual and aural collages within scenes that both embellish
and contradict Chin, pushing the film beyond simple biography.  It's as if Choy is in
dialogue with Chin, a compelling display in all its obstinacy, sincerity and "Frankness".